"You're A BAD BOY! YOU'RE A BAD BOY*******)?
A few seconds into it my MIL told him to sit still and be faint.
He made a real ugly frontage (mocking her) and told he "NO NANA! You go to timeout!!"
She in turn said to me that he be "Just a bad boy" . I went bad on her and said "He IS NOT a bay boy, just did somthing impossible... that doesn't make him a bad boy at adjectives!!"
She then turned to him and said"YOU'RE A BAD BOY! YOU'RE A BAD BOY*******... BAD BOY!!"
I went stale on her and demanded that she not talk to my child that way.
Everyone looked at me close to I was a monster an out of line.
Would you enjoy done the same thing?
Answers: I'm sure I would own gone off on her, too. I dread this kind of crap arranged with my own parents. Their parenting style is pretty violent. Since I know this just about my parents, weI actually sent them a letter that looked approaching I sent it to everyone we know, and it explained that our children have already suffered, and any violence would not be tolerated. That included VERBAL sternness (i.e. yelling, name-calling, taunting, etc., which is percieved as violence to a child's mind), and any violent behaviour between others. We explained that if we felt our child was not safe and sound, we would leave and come back another time.
I'm at work, otherwise I'd over-elaborate more. :-)
I wouldnt have gotten as angry as you did... He was making doomed to failure "choices".
If you go off on her that would be the lone reason I would have looked at you close to "a monster out of line" - Relax, your son wont be scarred this time- just variety sure you let people know your son doesnt necessitate to be drilled about being a bleak boy- ask them to replace it with he is making bad choices.
Act resembling an adult about it- even if your sis is mortal a child.
yes i would have done the same item no one should talk to your children resembling that, not even parents you do have to be strict but do it in a route that your children won't feel threatened and scared. i reflect you did the right thing telling your mother within law not to talk to your child close to that. and i think all of those citizens were just staring at you because they didn't know what you be yelling at her about if they know they all probably would have agreed beside you. i think that just because she's ur mother contained by law that doesn't mean she should do that! YOU are his parent! NOT her! i construe u should take her to the side and tell her that ur his mother and are surrounded by charge of his disiplin! she can go to you privately and give u warning but it is NOT her place to disiplin him! also if ur trying to disiplin him and she starts up trying to "help" it will confuse him.
I think you did the right point, I would probably had done the same entity, not in front of my kid but when you are mad you do not consider, at that age if you tell a kid that he is bad he will believe that he is, so do not agree to him believe that. Well for starters HELL YES! Your raising the boy not her,she should respect that and as for your MIL taughting him further with YOUR A BAD BOY crap is ridiculous! Shes a become fully grown woman what the hell?? And for goodness sack..HE'S 2! I personally man the person i am would have escorted her from my home! What she have taughted him with now could blemish that boy and possibly one day lead him to BE bleak,geez...kids pick up on that stuff they are sooo very receptive..You want to have a strong word with her
Yeah, I would own. I'd be pi$$ed if anyone would call my child that. He may have made a desperate choice, but he is not a bad boy. That must have also hurt his vibrations. At least your MIL should apologize to you and to your son for calling him that. Well your son should of not talk to her that approach. and u shouldnt of should that she did something wrong because she didnt. But it was wrong of her to swear at him.
I would have done exactly like thing and told her also that until she can talk to my child other and appropriately, she could just not be around him. I agree that she shouldn't be speaking to your son that way, but you should hold pulled her aside.One of you has to behave like an fully fledged...
Yes I would have dont the exact same thing, how dare she deed like that with your child. that be childish of her to do that! tell her to mind her own business and worry give or take a few her bad kids.
I would not tolerate such idiocy from my MIL.
You are right, it is your child, and you make the rules.
You did the right entity. I would had kicked her out of my house and told her never to come back! How DARE she?!! she have absoloutely NO right talking to him like that.!! Specially after you asked her not to!
Well duh. No one but me will have a word to my child that way if I had one. But whats an MIL? of corse i would i wouldn't consent to no one talk to him like that
Yes as you would expect! no one knows their child approaching the mother, and no one scolds or disciplines your child against your wishes especially surrounded by front of your child. when they take over in stead of you it shows encumbrance and kids will catch on even at 1 they can see who will get them their track and who will be mean, and who will be harsh but loving and they other come back to the harsh but loving. verbalize to her and tell her you dont want her to confront about your parenting within front of your son, go ahead and tell her if she ever have something to say to tell you when he isn't around, but you dont want him witnessing this argumenting or to see any sign of tenderness from either party. I work contained by a nursery and we make sure we never label a child, no concern what they do.labeling them "naughty, bad, silly" etc
It doesn't do them any apt to be called names, a moment ago will make them more frustrated even.
So we say if they own done something we don't wish them to do, that what they are doing or what they have done "made me have a feeling very sad" and then they are given their consequence if disobeying more than 3 times.
You be right to tell her not to speak to your son that way, but also remember that he should respect his Nana and shouldn't see you "going sour on one at her" either because he will think that explicitly right behaviour.
Trust me, even at 2, they will remember things for a long while and it will affect them unless it is explained to them, a little girl I know, her aunt come over and argued and shouted at her Mom, then the next few weeks they found their daughter shouting at her Mum alot and didn't know why and her dad sit her down, this was 2 weeks later, and he told her it wasn't nice ways, and she started mentioning about when Auntie Lena was shouting at Mommy!...everyone be very suprised lol and it stopped from there.
Maybe you should gossip to him about it, tell him that he wasn't awfully kind to Nana shouting at her and that you also shouldn't have argued next to Nana even tho you didn't agree with what she was motto to him.
Also, away from earshot of your son, maybe explain all your beliefs and wishes to his Nana, that you don't want her calling and labeling him a unpromising boy because it will only make him suggest that that is how he is and alas, he should act that track alot.
I probably would have done the same point in the heat of the moment, merely maybe at the time next time, pilfer a deep breath, tell your son that he shouldn't have a chat back to Nana and take Nana outta the room to narrate her what you think lol
Peace x
Wow! It's awful that you were put contained by this position, your MIL sounds like quite a nugget. She was wrong; however, you probably shouldn't have gone "off" on her contained by front of your son. You should have remained calm (easy for me to right to be heard here in my "arm chair"). You used the right words... my son is not bad, his demeanour is bad" You were right to defend your child, but you probably should hold kept your cool in front of him. Of course it's okay to "go off" when he is not around - you merely don't want to model behavour that he may pick up. Again, I recognize that it is easy counsel to give, but harder to act out on contained by the heat of the moment. I would have punished him for mortal disrespectful.
Negative actions deserve negative consequences.
How is supporting his movements by doing nothing about his whereabouts helping with discipline?
More Questions...