my toddler sleeps in her own bed, but in my bedroom. when should she get her own bedroom?


i currently live in a 1-bedroom apartment. my 21-month old sleeps in a toddler bed across the room. i'm moving soon, and was looking at both 1 and 2-bedroom apartments. i can save money by getting a 1-bedroom and sharing the room, as is status quo. or i can get a 2-bedroom and she can have her own space. at her mom's house, she shares a bedroom with her little sister.

my mom thinks i should get a 1-bedroom. she says i need to save the money and that she doesn't need her own bedroom till she's 3 or 4 years old.

on the other hand, my gf thinks i should get a 2-bedroom. she says that if CPS is called and i'm sharing a bedroom with my daughter, they'll take her away.

so, i just want to know which way i should go and what other people's experience in this area is. thanks!

Answers:
I think your girlfriend is just wanting privacy with you. The biggest issue here is how both you and your daughter feel about this. I strongly disagree with the Ferber method of seperating yourself from your child. How will she learn to trust anyone if she can't trust that you are there? I had my own bedroom as a child, but actually shared a bed with my parents from about the age of 2 to 3, when my mom got pregnant with my brother and they just explained to me that I couldn't share the bed with them because they had to protect the baby (I've always been a restless sleeper and I'd kick). So then I slept on a pile of pillows and blankets in their walk-in closet (by choice). I'd switch off. By the age of about 6 or so, I was back in my own room every night. I'm fine now, no dependency issues.

CPS would only take your daughter away if they have reasonable suspicion that you are molesting her, and just her sleeping in your room is not even close to enough evidence. Plenty of people can't afford two-bedroom spaces.

What can you afford? What would provide the best life for your daughter at this time? And the biggest question of all, has it really been much of a problem yet? If you feel the need for privacy, or she has expressed a desire to have her own space, then a 2-bedroom is probably the way to go. But if neither of you have a problem with it, why spend the extra money just yet? She's not even 2 yet, she probably feels tons of comfort knowing you're around.

The biggest thing I can stress to you is it really doesn't matter what anyone but you and her think. If you decide to get a 2-bedroom, if she still wants to sleep with you on and off, let her. Remember, you are going to a new place, it's hard to sleep in unfamiliar environments, so she's going to want to know you are there.

Other Answers:
definatley make her get her own bedroom

Children should sleep in their own rooms from the time they come home from the hospital. She should have her own room. She is developing a dependency on you that is not healthy. Also if you and your girlfriend are sleeping in the same room, it is obviously a very bad idea.


if you plan to have a intimate relationship with someone.. you must get you child a bedroom of their own.. children are not dumb and they know whats going on...

they wont take her away from you...and good for you most guys wouldnt care... now to answer your ? a 2 bedroom would be better so she could have space and that way you can get busy with out waking her up....if thats an issue*

I seriously doubt CPS is going to take your daughter away from you because she sleeps in the same room as you. You should be happy your daughter is even sleeping in her own bed, most babies don't even do that. If you think there is any truth that CPS will take her away, call and ask the laws. Also, you should check with your state about the laws for occupany. I know that when I had my son, my BF and I HAD to get a 2 bedroom because the State of Oklahoma will not allow 3 people to live in a one bedroom. Hope this info was helpful, good luck. I agree with the first three answers, definately get her her own room.

I did have my first in my bed with us for the first 2 years or so, and it was a royal pain. She's 5 & STILL wants to sleep with us all the time, and it's very annoying, but it's my own fault.

The second I had sleep in his own bed (in our room) after the first month. He did just fine. He is 3-1/2 and has his own room and does fine. I would have had the kids have their own rooms sooner, but it was a matter of space & logistics.

I think if it's possible to get her her own room, you should do so. It's better for her mental growth & development, and I think your friend has a point about CPS. It's better though to live your life so that CPS is not a presence in your life whatsoever- do whatever it takes. They have way, way too much power, and frankly CPS scares me to pieces.


Get a 2 bedroom. I live in Northern Nevada and as far as I know she would need her own room, the occupancy rules apply in Nevada and most apartment complexes, and even private owners, would tell you to take a two bedroom. And as someone wrote earlier, toddlers are not stupid; they soak up everything that they see like a sponge, if there is any sort of sexual contact between you and your girlfriend and she See's it there is a possibility that she will remember it subconsciously. The best thing to do.... Get a two bedroom.


She would probualy enjoy her own bedroom even if she is a little young, a place to feel safe and put her things, they like that and you need to make a big deal out of it for her..

get the two BR you will need privacy or if you don't she may not want to "move out" of your room at 3-4yrs old...WAtch the nanny on tv and the problems parents have tryting to get kids out of their room......

get a 2 bedroom when my daughter was born we only had a 1 bedroom for awhile and when we got a 2 bedroom it was hard to get her to sleep in her own room the younger they are to have their own room the better it will be my daugher loves her own room shes just turned 13 she goes and plays with her toys and stuff and as far as cps i have never heard of that in my country its perfectly normal and legal to let babies sleep in the room which u sleep in so move to the phillippines in south east asia our currency is peso 1 dollar is 52 pesos in our country your rich if u go here lots of dollars as long as u finished high school u can get a job but if u dont wanna move here get her a bedroom or let her sleep in the sofa


She probably won't even LIKE sleeping in another bedroom, so I would just stick with the one bedroom. I'm not sure about the laws in that state, though. If your girlfriend isn't mom she needs to BUTT OUT and let you raise your daughter. Mine are 4 years adn 16 months and BOTH sleep in my room.

ur moms completly right i have my son's bed in our since he was a baby and i gave him his own room but hes never in it he brings his toys in the living room and our edroom, so u could wait a bit before u get a 2 bedroom apartment and cps won't take her away, they have to prove u unfit, just sharing a room isn't unfit its quite commonsense, shes little i could see if she was 16 or something and still didn't have her own space but shes not even 2 and shes so small u can make her her own space in ur room hope that helps

Definitely the 2-bedroom. If you teach her to sleep in her own room at an early age, she'll think nothing of it. If not, she'll refuse to by the time she's 3-4. If you let her sleep in your room too long, she'll become scared of sleeping alone. And the CPS thing could definitely happen. I don't know about Nevada laws, but it could happen. So I really think the 2-bedroom is best. Hope I helped.



More Questions & Answers...
The information provided by website users, we do not guarantee its completeness and accuracy, so it can not be applied in during any medical emergency or for the diagnosis or treatment of any medical condition.
Copyright © 2007-2009 PPQnA.com All Rights Reserved. - Terms of Use - Contact Us

Pregnancy & Parenting