Is it time to reintroduce corporal punishment at academy as an successful form of discipline?
1) The policeman who gives children and teenagers a "clip around the ear"
2) Parents being competent to smack (but not hit) their offspring)
3) Children growing up to respect adults and knowing that if they don't, they will be made to feel small, hurt and upset
I don't mean to nouns Dickensian, but children and teenagers don't "know it all". They need to learn in the region of life. Not by means of verbal abuse, but simply good, old-fashioned discipline that will shock the child or youngster enough to make them behave.
Please, do not acquire physical discipline mixed up with abuse. There is a difference and, as responsible adults, we should stick to the rules surrounding it as well.
What does everybody else think?
Answers: I'd merely be happy with parents taking put a bet on up the cause in their homes. I've never be a big fan of school corporal punishment, but I'm not completely against it.
There be a time not to long ago (and this still holds true in my home today) where children be held accountable. If I was picking flowers out of my neighbor's garden next to out permission, my neighbor would march me right home and inform my parents. NOW here is the big difference between modern parents, and my parents. Modern parents would defend their child, or say something approaching "she's just a kid, get over it", "It be just a flower", or if your LUCKY they will apologies and tell the child not to do it again. Now MY PARENTS would own up to my room, over their lap, pants down, and spanking my naked bottom good. Then had me rear over to my neighbors home to apologies for my misbehavior. Guess what? I NEVER picked those flowers again without asking. I thank god everyday that my parents had the courage to do the tough stuff near us kids too. And lets just right to be heard, our girls are being raised alike way, with matching results. People didn't complain about the children back afterwards, but they do now, I wonder why. Children have become the spanking new pets for people, when they get bored beside them, they just cast them aside and forget something like raising them. Child rearing takes WORK, it's not adjectives fun and games, there is lots of hard work involved.
NO! No-one is my childrens parent but me and i would never hold allowed anyone to put their hands on my kids. In the uk parents ARE allowed to still 'smack' their children and no-one should ever want to move beyond that point of just a 'smack'. If they do, afterwards they shouldn't be parents! I preferred to warmly 'invite' my children to grow and now they're adjectives well adjusted adults, none of them enjoy been in trouble near such things as the police, drugs and alcohol and none of them were 'teenage' parents all waiting until they be in their twenties and in stable relationships. Children hold to be Nurtured, not beaten! hell no, I'm my child's parent. In no way is it OK for another personality take it upon themselves to punish my child in that bearing.
I had a teacher that favored corporal punishment growing up as a kid, guess what, not once did a spank near or without a damn paddle ever seize me to change my ways. Guidance and finding the way on my own allowed me to grow into the full-size I am today.
I think it should at school I be punished and knew If I did wrong I`d be punished again.kids nowadays contemplate they have the right to be rude disruptive and can do anything without mortal punished.a clip around the ear from a copper was worse than courts and parents gave you another for person "naughty" so yes disciple needs to be brought back. At institution no way. I don't want anyone.and won't have anyone touching my children up at their arts school. What is the difference in a smack and hitting someone anyway? Physical discipline (if that's the way you choose to parent) should own no place anywhere other than in the home.
It wouldn't be possible surrounded by a school anyway with the tenet suit crazy world we live in today.
No way. Most teacher are against using the cane in school anyway as they can see it doesn't work.
I was never smacked or slapped and I turned out okay! come to Africa and see how children behave.Viva corporal punishment
Yes. Not at all, I would not trust a character I don't know with that type of punishments on my children. If you think that nearby won't be abuse, then you're an idiot.
Children should NEVER be qualified to respect adults based on age. Respect is earned base on one's character, not birthdate. They also should NEVER be told that adults are always right. That is why they are so well abused, because if they were raised to never quiz an adult, then how are they supposed to ever shield themselves when it comes to abuse?
Also, how is hitting children "teaching them in the region of life?" It's nothing but bullying.
You are right! children and teenagers do not know it adjectives. That is why we, their parents, are here, to teach them about the world and cause them better persons. To me, a parent who uses corporal punishment is just showing his/her breakdown as parent.
Children are not dumb. They only need mercy, love and explanation. That is our role as parents.
My dad used corporal punishment with my brother and I. He never had the restraint, nor the time, to talk to us, teach us, comfort us, edify us. It was easier to just to 'punish' us.
I grew up hate him and has taken me some time to start talking to him.
Old-fashioned discipline contained by today's world is for people who have low self-esteem and are not adjectives. I'd like to thik we have more erudite people now :)
More Questions...